Not using alternative methods
The mass killing of male chicks is no longer an issue in certain EU Member States. Germany and France are examples of countries where the systematic mass killing of male chicks in egg-laying factory farms is banned, and technology that can sex the chicks whilst they are still in the egg has instead been promoted.
In-ovo sexing
In-ovo sexing is a technology that makes it possible to sort out male chicks before they have hatched. There are various methods available on the market, and several more are currently being developed. Technology for in-ovo sexing is already in use in hatcheries in countries including Norway, Germany, France, Italy, the USA and Brazil.
Male chicks suffer when they are killed on their first day of life, but the ability to feel and process pain has already developed while they are still in the egg. However, research is not unanimous on exactly when the chick embryo develops the ability to experience pain; various studies point to times around day 11,4 day 13,5 and day 16–17.6 Sorting of the eggs should therefore take place as early as possible to reduce the risk of suffering, preferably before day seven in the incubator.7
Dual-purpose breeds
However, in-ovo sexing does not solve the animal welfare and ethical issues associated with factory farming. Another alternative is therefore to transition the egg industry to so-called dual-purpose breeds. These are breeds in which the hens lay a relatively high number of eggs, whilst the roosters grow faster and develop more muscle than roosters from breeds bred for high egg production.
The use of dual-purpose breeds would address the killing of newly hatched male chicks and reduce suffering in the egg and meat industries, as dual-purpose breeds have been shown to have fewer animal welfare issues than laying hens and Frankenchicks bred for high production.8,9,10 The introduction of dual-purpose breeds must be carried out in connection with an increase in plant-based production and consumption, so as not to increase the number of animals in factory farms.